CodeHawks Escrow Contract - Competition Details

Contest Details

• Total Prize Pool: $40,000
  • HM Awards: $37,000
  • LQAG Awards: $3,000
• Starts July 24, 2023
• Ends August 5th, 2023
• nSLOC: ~182
• Complexity Score: ~106

Project Overview

Actors

• Buyer: The purchaser of services, in this scenario, a project purchasing an audit.
• Seller: The seller of services, in this scenario, an auditor willing to audit a project.
• Arbiter: An impartial, trusted actor who can resolve disputes between the Buyer and Seller. ​ Design considerations
• The Arbiter is only compensated the arbiterFee amount if a dispute occurs.
• Once a dispute has been initiated it can not be canceled.
• ERC777 tokens should not be used as tokens for the Escrow contract given that it enables a malicious buyer to DOS Escrow::resolveDispute
• In case a smart contract calls EscrowFactory::newEscrow, given that the caller of this contract is in control of the salt, frontrunning is a possibility. ​

Workflows

Create an Escrow

1. Buyer approves the payment contract to be handled by EscrowFactory.
2. Buyer calls EscrowFactory::newEscrow, inputs:
   1. The price.
   2. The payment token.
   3. The seller (auditor or person in charge of the audit).
   4. Arbiter.
   5. Arbiter fee: Fee to pay in case of a dispute is initialized.
   6. Salt: for create2 Escrow deployment.

Expected sucessful workflow

1. The buyer creates an Escrow contract through EscrowFactory::newEscrow, depositing the funds.
2. The seller sends the buyer the report (off-chain).
3. The buyer acknowledges this report on-chain by calling Escrow::confirmReceipt. This sends the funds to the seller.

​ Expected dispute workflow

1. The buyer creates an Escrow contract through EscrowFactory::newEscrow, depositing the funds.
2. For any reason, the buyer or the seller can initiate a dispute through Escrow::initiateDispute.
3. The arbiter confers with both parties offchain. Arbiter then calls Escrow::resolveDispute, reimbursing either side accordingly, emptying the Escrow. ​

Submissions

• Submit to CodeHawks

In Scope

All contracts in src are in scope.

Note on script folder: The contracts in script are the scripts you can assume are going to be used to deploy and interact with the contracts. If they have an issue that will affect the overall security of the system, they are in scope. However, if they have a security issue that only affects the script and not the overall deployment of the escrow protocol, it is out of scope.

Known Issues

• Addresses other than the zero address (for example 0xdead) could prevent disputes from being resolved - Before the buyer deploys a new Escrow, the buyer and seller should agree to the terms for the Escrow. If the buyer accidentally or maliciously deploys an Escrow with incorrect arbiter details, then the seller could refuse to provide their services. Given that the buyer is the actor deploying the new Escrow and locking the funds, it's in their best interest to deploy this correctly.
• Large arbiter fee results in little/no seller payment - In this scenario, the seller can decide to not perform the audit. If this is the case, the only way the buyer can receive any of their funds back is by initiating the dispute process, in which the buyer loses a large portion of their deposited funds to the arbiter. Therefore, the buyer is disincentivized to deploy a new Escrow in such a way.
• Tokens with callbacks allow malicious sellers to DOS dispute resolutions - Each supported token will be vetted to be supported. ERC777 should be discouraged.
• buyer never calls confirmReceipt - The terms of the Escrow are agreed upon by the buyer and seller before deploying it. The onus is on the seller to perform due diligence on the buyer and their off-chain identity/reputation before deciding to supply the buyer with their services.
• salt input when creating an Escrow can be front-run
• arbiter is a trusted role
• User error such as buyer calling confirmReceipt too soon
• Non-tokenAddress funds locked

About

This project is meant to enable smart contract auditors (sellers) and smart contract protocols looking for audits (buyers) to connect using a credibly neutral option, with optional arbitration.

• CodeHawks Escrow Contract - Competition Details
  • Contest Details
    • Project Overview
    • Workflows
  • Submissions
  • In Scope
  • Known Issues
• About
• Getting Started
  • Requirements
  • Quickstart
• Usage
  • Testing
    • Test Coverage
  • Start a local node
  • Deploy
  • Deploy - Other Network
• Deployment to a testnet or mainnet
  • Estimate gas
• Formatting
• Acknowledgements

Getting Started

Requirements

• git
  • You'll know you did it right if you can run git --version and you see a response like git version x.x.x
• foundry
  • You'll know you did it right if you can run forge --version and you see a response like forge 0.2.0 (816e00b 2023-03-16T00:05:26.396218Z)

Quickstart

git clone https://github.com/Cyfrin/2023-07-escrow 
cd escrow 
forge build

Usage

Testing

forge test

Test Coverage

forge coverage

and for coverage based testing:

forge coverage --report debug

Start a local node

make anvil

Deploy

This will default to your local node. You need to have it running in another terminal in order for it to deploy.

make deploy

Deploy - Other Network

See below

Deployment to a testnet or mainnet

1. Setup environment variables

You'll want to set your SEPOLIA_RPC_URL and PRIVATE_KEY as environment variables. You can add them to a .env file, similar to what you see in .env.example.

• PRIVATE_KEY: The private key of your account (like from metamask). NOTE: FOR DEVELOPMENT, PLEASE USE A KEY THAT DOESN'T HAVE ANY REAL FUNDS ASSOCIATED WITH IT.
  • You can learn how to export it here.
• SEPOLIA_RPC_URL: This is url of the goerli testnet node you're working with. You can get setup with one for free from Alchemy

Optionally, add your ETHERSCAN_API_KEY if you want to verify your contract on Etherscan.

1. Get testnet ETH

Head over to faucets.chain.link and get some tesnet ETH. You should see the ETH show up in your metamask.

2. Deploy

make deploy ARGS="--network sepolia"

Estimate gas

You can estimate how much gas things cost by running:

forge snapshot

And you'll see and output file called .gas-snapshot

Formatting

To run code formatting:

forge fmt

Acknowledgements

• Inspiration for the codebase from Ross Campbell